Finding Identity When “Who Am I” is a Moving Target
When I was forming my identity, I looked up to my sister and “crazy aunt Sally” because they always spoke their truth. I admired Pippi Longstocking and Punky Brewster because they were free spirits. Later PJ Harvey and Shirley Manson put melodies to my emotions and I discovered a shared artistic sensibility with Baz Lurhman, Spike Lee, and Phillip Seymour Hoffman.
I knew very little about most of these people, but they each helped shape who I am today. Who are the current role models shaping our future?
Harry Potter, Frodo, Morpheus from the Matrix. Malala, Caitlyn Jenner, Obama. Kesha, Lady Gaga, Russell Brand. The images and ideologies around these figures serve an important role in our society. They are archetypes.
Their stories make up myths that define our culture. And myths are how societies dictate their place in history. They are meant to be a guide to help navigate the social environment. No one understood this better than Carl Jung.
American mythologist Joseph Campbell popularized Jung’s ideas in The Hero’s Journey. He said, “The first function of mythology is showing everything as a metaphor to transcendence.” Campbell’s protege Phil Cousineau explains:
“The journey of the hero is about the eternal cycle of change within us; the uncanny discovery that the seeker is the mystery which the seeker seeks to know. The hero journey is a symbol that binds, in the original sense of the word, two distant ideas, the spiritual quest of the ancients with the modern search for identity, always the one, shape-shifting yet marvelously constant story that we find.”
This work suggests that the search for identity is an inner journey that works its way out, in contrast to external forces (i.e media/corporate America/government) shaping individuals from the outside in. Which do you prefer: finding your own voice or confirming to popular culture?
What happens if you don’t know what your inner voice is saying? Maybe you don’t recognize it or speak its language? What if it isn’t even defined yet….?
Consider struggling artists. Some might be struggling with depression because they are juggling a “day job.” Some might be scraping to survive on their art alone. Some might be addicts or just simply misunderstood (not only by others, but by themself).
These are the people who grew up being told everything they did was wrong or not important; who discover that the dominating authority always has the last say, the best deal, and all the control. That sounds like something to strive for if your whole life has been on the short-end of the stick.
Social psychologist Henri Tajfel’s 1979 study proposed that groups are “an important source of pride and self-esteem. Groups give us a sense of social identity: a sense of belonging to the social world.”
But just as our society is regularly changing and evolving, so too is our ‘identity’ a moving target. Which is why it is a great tragedy of our culture that we are taught to value finish lines, bottom lines, and end-goals at the expense of all else. Corporations will look the other way if you exceed expectations that fuel growth.
We’re told to get to the point and get to it fast, or we get voted off the island. You certainly won’t get any funding from Shark Tank. You only have 2 minutes to impress the judges on America’s Got Talent or they won’t even turn around to look at you. And in those 2 minutes you have to somehow express your identity...
But if “Who am I” is a life-long search, how can anyone fit themselves into these molds? It seems fraudulent, or at the very least, inauthentic. And obliging this dictate of society comes with strings attached.
Conforming to social pressure compromises our own integrity. Once assigned a social group, it excludes all else. Tajfel’s study concluded with Social Identity Theory, which explains the slippery slope from “belonging” to “prejudice”:
“We see the group to which we belong (the in-group) as being different from the others (the out-group), and members of the same group as being more similar than they [in fact] are. Social categorization is one explanation for prejudice attitudes (i.e. “them” and “us” mentality).”
Further studies have proven that people become blind to truth if it contradicts their beliefs. The Atlantic’s Julie Beck analyzed why people believe “fake news” in “This Article Won’t Change Your Mind:”
“[I]f the thing you might be wrong about is a belief that’s deeply tied to your identity or worldview—[your] guru is accused of terrible things, the cigarettes you’re addicted to can kill you—well, then people [do] all the mental gymnastics it takes to remain convinced that they’re right.”
This is why the search for identity must have role models. This is called the “Meeting of the Mentor,” step 4 of the Hero’s Journey. The mentor is not necessarily human; it could be a representation or situation.
Survivalist Ed Stafford found his mentor in nature. He experienced the ‘enormity’ of social isolation while living alone in the Amazon for 2½ years, including 60 days on a remote island. In an interview on Russell Brand’s podcast Under the Skin, Stafford says people tend to define their lives by how their behavior, ideas, and actions “bounce off other people.”
While in isolation there were no reactions from which to bounce his thoughts off, no one to judge him or from whom he could measure himself against. All he could do was bounce definitions off the only person who was present: his authentic self.
That’s an awesome way to find your inner voice. But disappearing into isolation for 60 days is an extreme route, and certainly not sustainable.
A more realistic path to defining “Who am I?” is to surround yoursef by authentic, honest, and good people. Definitions that “bounce off” these people will be much more holistic and pure. This is the Mirror Effect. It’s definitely better than the alternative unhealthy, exploitive leeches that are found in abundance around the Arts.
It’s never been more important than right now, when there seems to be a disconnect between our socio-political realities and our personal lives. The current social discourse around identity is based on dichotomies: gender, race, sexual orientation, #MeToo, #BlackLivesMatter, and even #GunControl. And yet the messaging behind every movement is asking for unity and freedom for all.
This disconnect makes finding your inner voice confusing. If the predominant authority, in this case our government and corporate systems, is reflecting a warped version of reality, life becomes awkward and uncomfortable. Sound familiar?
We're currently at the crossroads of a cultural revolution, when artistic representations of myths and role models are needed most. Wesley Morris paints the backdrop nicely in his New York Times 2015 article The Year We Obsessed Over Identity:
"And where are we? On one hand: in [a melodramatic slapstick movie]. On the other: in the midst of a great cultural identity migration. Gender roles are merging. Races are being shed. In the last six years or so we’ve been made to see how trans and bi and poly-ambi-omni- we are.
This is a country founded on independence and yet comfortable with racial domination, a country that has forever been trying to legislate the lines between whiteness and nonwhiteness, between borrowing and genocidal theft. We’ve wanted to think we’re better than a history we can’t seem to stop repeating."
And yet, even as we are doomed to repeat the past, life is evolving. National Geographic’s special edition, “The Race Issue,” suggests These Twins, One Black and One White, Will Make You Rethink Race:
“[W]hen the twins are asked about their differences, they mention something else entirely. ‘Millie likes things that are girlie. She likes pink and all of that,’ Marcia says. ‘I don’t like the color pink; I’m a tomboy. People are made how they are.’”
Let our current realities be only a frame for the world we create. We are not only defining ourselves, we are defining our place in history; the myths for future generations to define themselves against.
As new role models are coming forward every day, we must remember the lessons from previous cultural revolutions: the Great Depression, Woman’s Suffrage, Civil Rights Movement, the hippie rebellion, and even Wikileaks. The people who fought the social barriers of their times were speaking their truths in that moment.
Most of us understand that it takes great risk to speak up, especially considering the dangers of Social Identity Theory. Proceeding in the face of risk is what makes those situations and leaders pivotal to future generations. Their stories carve #AnotherWay for people to see themselves from an authentic perspective instead of an institutional dictum.
Not everyone has a “crazy aunt Sally,” or any positive role model in their life at all. But we can still find transcendence by using the Mirror Effect with personal relationships and archetypes. “Who Am I” is a journey, not a destination.
Emileena's upcoming book is ANOTHER WAY, The Tao of Artist Development. To learn more about her work, please visit www.theshowgoesonproductions.com.
Original Artwork by Dave Law, freelance visual artist and illustrator. For more, please visit www.davelawart.com.
If you are an artist looking for development, consider Emileena's E-Velop program.